Late this past week, a good friend – on substantive issues, more liberal than I am — celebrated a birthday, and in response to our Happy Birthday text, responded in effect, “It’ll be happier if I don’t have to read one of your posts today” – i.e., he didn’t want to be reminded on his birthday of the dire dangers I keep maintaining in these pages that our democracy now faces. I burst out laughing; it was the only moment of humor – albeit gallows — I’ve felt for quite a while about how things are developing, and the only note of levity that will appear in this post. His wish was granted; I had nothing scheduled to run that day, but would have deferred any scheduled entry if there had been.
His birthday is now past. If today is your birthday, I strongly suggest you that now exit this site.
You don’t need me to recount the details of ICE agents’ murder of Alex Pretti in Minneapolis on January 24. It is apparently undisputed that Mr. Pretti was an American citizen, a VA intensive-care nurse with no criminal record. He was carrying a concealed firearm at the time he was accosted by ICE, but multiple credible outlets have reported that he had the legal permits to do so and the New York Times is reporting that there is no sign in videos that Mr. Pretti “pulled his weapon, or that agents even knew he had one until he was already pinned on the sidewalk.” Virtually any video of the incident makes clear that multiple ICE agents were all over this one man. I understand that there are estimates that Mr. Pretti was shot up to 10 times.
Minneapolis is now in tumult. MN Gov. Tim Walz has activated the Minnesota National Guard to try to keep order. How these troops will interact with the federal ICE agents remains to be seen.
You’ve already heard more than enough from me in recent days; until Mr. Pretti’s murder, I had intended to give both you and me a break for a while. Of the points made below, the one that primarily prompted me to enter this note is the reference to a potential coming culmination near its conclusion.
The fact that a number of Regime officials, including Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, were already publicly exonerating the ICE agents and defaming Mr. Pretti as a domestic terrorist before – as anyone with the IQ of a rock should realize — the Regime could possibly have had time to collect and verify the facts of the shooting, demonstrates that the Regime has no interest in fairness or truth; that, to paraphrase Comedian Jon Stewart’s comment a while back about President Donald Trump’s holding a Great Gatsby Party while millions were having their food assistance cut off: The Regime doesn’t give a f—k about even looking like it gives a f—k. They don’t give a f—k – at all. (I know; I just wasted your time with the obvious; couldn’t help myself; I apologize.)
At the same time, I predict that this recent shooting will not reduce Mr. Trump’s dismal approval ratings, or the public’s now-decidedly negative view of his immigration enforcement, by more than another a point or two. Any citizen who is paying attention and was willing to believe his/her own eyes made up his/her mind about the Regime’s ICE’s Nazi Sturmabteilung-like activities in the days following ICE’s murder of Renee Good. Any such citizen didn’t need another murder to be convinced.
Now, to the most chilling: it is apparently undisputed that in a Saturday letter to Mr. Walz, Attorney General Pam Bondi offered to “bring an end to the chaos in Minnesota” – which one can reasonably infer is an offer by the Regime to tone down ICE agents’ activities — in return for several Minnesota state concessions including, most ominously, turning Minnesota voter rolls over to the Department of Justice (DOJ) to “confirm that Minnesota’s voter registration practices comply with federal law.” Again, you don’t need me to point out that this is a blatant attempt to gain information which will facilitate the Regime’s subversion of the upcoming 2026 federal elections in a “blue” state. A point I find intriguing that I haven’t seen anybody else make is that it was Ms. Bondi who made this blatantly extortive and extralegal demand. Ms. Bondi’s job is to prosecute those who are violating federal law. She has nothing to do, per se, with immigration enforcement. That is Ms. Noem’s job; it is Ms. Noem who has the authority to turn up or down ICE enforcement. The fact that Ms. Bondi made the offer to reduce ICE pressure in return for Minnesota’s providing the Regime access to state’s voter rolls – which obviously have nothing to do with immigration enforcement — shows the concerted, coordinated nature of the Regime’s attack on both our civil rights and our electoral processes.
An aside; I just can’t resist a comment on the Second Amendment-obsessed, MAGA-related irony tragically apparent in Mr. Pretti’s death. Much of the justification of the ICE agents’ shooting of Mr. Pretti has focused on Mr. Pretti’s possession of a firearm (of which they weren’t even aware, when they first wrestled him to the ground), and the risk that the agents allegedly felt when they discovered the gun – despite Mr. Pretti’s legal right to carry the weapon the way he did, and video proving that he did not pull or brandish it at officials as Regime officials have falsely claimed (and that an ICE agent had indeed taken the weapon from him before they killed him). Now, correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t much of MAGA’s spirited defense of the Second Amendment based upon the premise that the Amendment is needed to enable a citizen to protect him/herself against unconstitutional governmental overreach? Here, a fascist regime is using a citizen’s legal possession of a weapon which he did not draw as a rationale for … killing him. Again, if this wasn’t so gut-wrenching, you couldn’t make this stuff up.
Another aside, which I would submit is extremely important for our democracy: the current battle between Netflix and Paramount for the acquisition of Warner Brothers, which, among its other properties, owns CNN. CNN is amongst the least commercially valuable of Warner Brothers’ assets that will be obtained by its new owner, but the transfer of CNN ownership is clearly very important to Mr. Trump, who wants to see Warner Brothers sold to Paramount – controlled by the Ellison family, vigorous Trump supporters – rather than to Netflix. The Warner Brothers Board of Directors keeps trying to fend off Paramount offers, and to sell to Netflix. May its efforts be successful. All that read these pages are well aware of our affinity for MSNOW’s Morning Joe, but when news happens, we don’t turn our TV to MSNOW, but to CNN (sorry, Joe 😉). While covering Mr. Pretti’s murder, CNN has minced no words demonstrating that ICE’s justifications are hogwash. If the Ellison family gains control of CNN, CNN’s factual reporting will stop the day after the takeover is finalized. For the good of democracy, we need CNN to remain one of our now alarmingly-dwindling, widely-disseminated credible news outlets.
Of course, Mr. Walz and the Minnesota legislature are not going to agree to surrender the state’s voter rolls to the Regime. Such a surrender would be the equivalent of Denmark giving up Greenland to the United States. Which means that ICE will continue its brutal activities, and despite the efforts of Minnesota’s National Guard, the unrest in Minneapolis may likely correspondingly escalate. Where we are is what happens next.
Within the past week – it seems like weeks ago, but we’re in Trump time – I ventured that if Mr. Trump ordered a military invasion of Greenland, as he was then threatening, the presence of waiting NATO troops meant that there would be shooting, and that both American and NATO troops would die. I further ventured that if such occurred, given the vast majority of Americans’ disagreement with Mr. Trump’s intentions to invade an ally, those dead soldiers would mean the end of his presidency in the democratic sense – that he would then either become a lame duck with three years formally remaining in his term, or, to maintain de facto control of the country, that he would then have to declare Martial Law and institute a dictatorship. I will pose that if continuing brutal ICE activities incite accelerating unrest in Minneapolis, the President will soon be placed in the same political position as he would have been had he invaded Greenland. If he cites the Insurrection Act and deploys active-duty military to the streets of Minneapolis – which will already have a blizzard of Minnesota National Guard, ICE agents, and Minneapolis law enforcement on the scene, the closest we have had to a militarily-occupied city since the end of the Civil War — riots will ensue. Most Americans will conclude that he is deploying military against American citizens to quell unrest that he precipitated. It will mean the end of his presidency in the democratic sense. He will then either resign himself to being an emasculated lame duck – which I would submit is not within his compass — or he will be willing to declare Martial Law and to in effect institute a dictatorship.
I wouldn’t venture a wager as to how events will now go. Mr. Trump is not a strategist; in any encounter, he seemingly never has any specific “end result” in mind; he thinks tactically — he simply pushes as hard as he can, and sees how the other side reacts. Despite his reputation for “doubling down” when confronted, if he sees that events in a given situation are not shaping up to his liking and that he doesn’t have an overwhelming advantage, he will – as he did in Greenland — look for a face-saving measure to step back from the brink. To the extent that he is not consumed by delusion, I would expect that he will see that any further escalation in Minnesota will narrow his options to the two above. He may not – at least yet – want to go there. Or he might. I would forthrightly predict a hypertoxic confrontation if White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller – who is, more than Ms. Noem, truly the architect of the ICE enforcement approach – was making the final call; but as I observed in an earlier note on Greenland, Mr. Miller was the Administration official making the most bellicose declarations about military deployment there, but in the last analysis, Mr. Trump – who clearly is still the boss – had no trouble undercutting him. The Regime’s offer to Mr. Walz, no matter who made it, may have been its first maneuver to step back from the brink.
We’ll see what happens.
After the Pretti shooting, another friend – now closely following events, but who hasn’t spent a lifetime being a Political Science/Policy/History geek – mentioned to me at being literally shocked that the Regime, despite all existing video evidence in the Good and Pretti murders, would simply lie to the American people about what had happened, and keep on lying. The comment made me pause and reflect: although I am outraged, saddened, and a number of other emotions at the Regime’s activities, why am I not shocked at the Regime’s systemic lying? The answer came readily enough: because I am a lifetime Political Science/Policy/History geek, and once I internalized – in the last year and a half of the President’s first term — that Donald Trump and his true cohort had fascist tendencies, watching them lie, as abhorrent as it is, has been no more surprising to me than the punchline of the story of the scorpion who stings the frog swimming the spider to safety.
It’s just their nature.
Even if it’s not your birthday — too dark, you say? Let us hope so. Whether he will publicly admit it or not, Mr. Trump is clearly acutely aware that if traditional federal electoral processes are allowed to proceed unfettered this November as they have for the last 250 years, Republicans (and thus, he himself; he is the Republican brand) are likely to receive such a resounding rejection that not even he will be able to blame it on election fraud. One has to have significant doubt that his fragile ego can face such a prospect. As I have suggested on one earlier occasion, I think what will ultimately transpire – if not in the near term, at some point in the future — is more likely to depend not on how far Mr. Trump and his cohort are willing to go, but upon how far our professional military is willing to follow them. Will our commanders and soldiers – not Mr. Trump’s ICE thugs – follow any Regime orders to forcefully subdue peaceful American citizen demonstrators?
I apologize at the blizzard of posts that I have dumped upon you in the last week. Although I am honored that you read them, I can well understand that you could feel that enough is enough. I may not, as I anticipated before Mr. Pretti’s killing, post for a while; on the other hand, if there is yet another new Regime outrage today, I might post tomorrow. The catharsis that posting in these pages provides is, at this point, for me their most valuable attribute; if you are finding the notes exhausting – as I think our friend who just celebrated his birthday does, although I’m pretty confident that he agrees with their substance – just delete ‘em. Give it a rest for a while.
No matter what, if one wishes to oppose Regime activities, always stay peaceful. If those who oppose the Regime fail to remain peaceful, all is lost practically and morally. But be ready for what comes next.
The fate of our democracy could be coming sooner than I thought.