On April 19, 2022, MI State Sen. Mallory McMorrow, describing herself as a “straight, white, Christian, married, suburban Mom,” having been attacked by a Republican adversary for “grooming and sexualizing children,” took to the floor of the Michigan State Senate and delivered a blistering response to the attack that proceeded to go viral. You may well have already seen it. A link to a YouTube video of her speech is set forth below.
On April 30, 2022, The New York Times published a detailed article on the manner and messages of Fox News Channel Commentator Tucker Carlson. Mr. Carlson is apparently the highest-rated host on cable news channels. (It appears from the report that Mr. Carlson’s audience is almost exclusively white and “overwhelmingly” older.) I have neither the strength of stomach nor sufficient remaining life space to devote attention to Mr. Carlson’s broadcasts, and thus, cannot independently vouch for the veracity of the Times’ account; with that disclaimer, the gist of the Times article seems to align with numerous other reports I have seen of Mr. Carlson’s program over the last several years. (Mr. Carlson has reportedly relished rather than disputed the Times report.) A link to the online version of the Times piece is also set forth below; hopefully, you can access it.
The Times indicates (and demonstrates through video) that Mr. Carlson frequently makes use of a “You – They” dichotomy in his monologues: You for his viewers, and They for those he calls the “Ruling Class” that he claims seeks to denigrate, among others, whites and men: the Ruling Class that hates You, that wants to control You, that wants to replace You with malleable (colored) immigrants. Feeding fear and dissatisfaction has made his ratings go higher and higher (arguably akin to setting up a salt lick for deer hunting). (I did find it particularly cruelly hypocritical for Mr. Carlson to call the Mainstream Media a “Propaganda Machine” for describing the January 6 Capitol uprising as an “insurrection,” when it is patently obvious to anybody with at least one eye that the riot was, indeed, a Trumplican insurrection.)
Sen. McMorrow’s remarks and the Times’ report of Mr. Carlson’s premises have caused me to revisit reflections I’ve had since the political rise of former President Donald Trump upon the contradictions implicit in the way that the political alt-right views some of those who do not adhere to its views.
Sen. McMorrow clearly thinks enough of public service to have placed herself in the political arena. TLOML and I have been voting and paying taxes for longer than Ms. McMorrow has been alive, have held down jobs, attended town halls, church socials, and parent-teacher meetings, coached Little League and led Brownie Troops. We shovel our snow and mow our lawn (sometimes, we even fertilize). Like Ms. McMorrow, we are straight, white, Christian, married, and parents. (We are also grandparents.) [I do fit in the “overwhelming older” segment of the Fox audience 😉 ]. By these measures, all three of us are presumably upstanding Fox Nation Real Americans.
That said, while I feel no guilt about being white, I certainly don’t feel under attack because of it; it’s pretty obvious that at least in America, it’s easier to be white than not. Although white birth rates are declining, I have yet to hear of any white couples who say that they have had fewer children than they wished because immigrants of other colors invaded their homes and forcibly kept them apart. I feel no threat from those of other races and ethnicities attempting to get ahead; this is America. (I favor equal treatment, not favoritism – in either direction.) I don’t feel under attack because I’m straight; again, in America, and I suspect in just about everywhere else in the world, it’s easier to be straight than not. If those of other gender and sexual orientations find solace in expressions that seem unusual to me, I don’t see how such harms me. (I find the notion that “unconventional” gender and sexual orientations are not inherent, but rather, can be “taught,” to be – stated tactfully – misguided.) I don’t feel that my Christian faith is succumbing to non-Christian elements; even aside from my personal belief that Christianity is but one of many paths to the Almighty, of one thing I’m absolutely certain: He (please excuse the male pronoun) can take care of Himself. On top of that, I’m male. Again, I feel no guilt about it, but certainly don’t feel threatened because of it. I don’t think that any foreigner has stolen any of my testosterone. If any of Mr. Carlson’s male viewers feel so endangered by the advance of women in our society that they would prefer to be female – and assume the burdens of dealing with oblivious males, conflicting societal expectations, etc., etc. — the line forms to the right. While Mr. Carlson is absolutely correct that those in our country with greater opportunities have frequently exploited those with fewer advantages, I would also suggest that some who focus on their disadvantages refuse to recognize that they didn’t always see or seize the opportunities available to them to better their situations.
Sen. McMorrow is one state legislator in one state’s legislature. I have been rereading approvingly – ever more so as the alt-right intensity has seemingly increased since the 2020 election — The Federalist articles of Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay and the discourses of John Locke and Winston Churchill – odes to the “Western Civilization” that Mr. Carlson claims to be under siege. Even so, neither Ms. McMorrow nor I look like the “Ruling Class” to me. Despite Mr. Carlson’s rants, I don’t hate – and sincerely doubt she hates — the ordinary Carlson viewer. I don’t wish – and sincerely doubt she wishes — to control the ordinary Carlson viewer. I don’t want – and sincerely doubt she wants — to replace the ordinary Carlson viewer. We simply believe that the promise of America embraces more than a single race, a single gender preference, a single faith.
So where do she and I fit within the Alt-Right Compass, given our Whiteness, our Straightness, our Christianity, our Good Citizenship, and the fact that we obviously don’t rule anybody?
Sen. McMorrow called it in her speech, either deliberately or inadvertently invoking Mr. Carlson’s framework: “[Because I have a different view than my Republican adversary] … you dehumanize and marginalize me … I am one of them.”
In his book, Anti-Pluralism, William Galston quotes Mr. Trump as saying at a May, 2016, rally: “The only important thing is the unification of the people … the other people don’t mean anything. [Emphasis Added]” In Foxconned – a book given me by a close friend detailing the Republican-fostered Wisconsin debacle that merits more extensive treatment in these pages before the 2022 elections — Lawrence Tabak quotes former WI Gov. Scott Walker as saying that it was a “flawed argument” that “a vote in [progressive] Madison [where TLOML and I reside] counts the same as a vote in a very rural community or in a suburban community.”
So it’s not enough even if one is, demographically, what the alt-right claims to appreciate. Those that don’t think like they do can’t “mean anything,” their votes can’t “count,” elections lost by alt-right candidates must be “stolen” … because good people wrapping themselves in rhetoric such as Mr. Carlson’s would otherwise have to admit, even to themselves, that they no longer believe in democracy.