[I apologize for the length of this post. It’s by far the longest I’ve ever entered – one might think that I’m trying out for The New Yorker 😉 — but I saw no good way to split it up without losing continuity. If you make it all the way to the end, I commend your perseverance. 😊]
In the 9+ years I’ve been doing this (yes, you long-time sufferers, it has been that long 😉), I have frequently regretted that I have devoted so much of this space to politics – the sports pages of our public discourse — and less to addressing substantive policy issues. In retrospect, President Donald Trump made the shift inevitable. However, I’ve come to realize: that a sustainable democracy is the foundation of all we have; that you can’t have a true democracy unless all of your citizens have the right to … vote; that all of our people, be their focus short- or long-term, are understandably most concerned about what they perceive to be best for them and families; and that – regrettably, but I would submit, irrefutably – an uncomfortably large segment of our people, profoundly influenced by our digital world, have ever-shorter attention spans and are ever-more-susceptible to having their biases and passions aroused by shiny baubles. Politics is substantive policy. As Theodore H. White commented in The Making of the President 1960: “[P]ublic affairs and politics are linked as are love and sex.” Mr. Trump has demonstrated how easily a significant segment of our electorate can be swayed. If we “lose” the persuadable part of this segment, we lose our democracy. I don’t think that it’s an overstatement to suggest that Democrats’ primary strategic objective in the coming year should be to start reconvincing a large segment of Americans that government can work for them. Only Mr. Trump’s hubris, greed, and caprice over the last two years have given Democrats – and us — a chance to preserve our democracy. You play the hand you’re dealt.
Since the election, I have received notes from several friends setting forth ambitious goals for the Democrats when their significant majorities assume control of Congress in 2027. Substantively, I agree with almost all of their suggestions. That said, what I outline below is less sweeping than some have offered, and in my view best designed to strengthen what I consider the fragile majority established in the last election. If Democrats are effective in 2027, in 2028 we will be likely to elect a president with sufficient majorities in both houses of Congress to reinforce our shaken democratic institutions and norms and to lead us in addressing our many fundamental challenges that can’t be addressed while Mr. Trump is president. If they aren’t, we may well not. We’ve dug ourselves a deep hole over the last decade. We’ve got to climb out one foot at a time.
Back to 2027, and reality: Mr. Trump will still be President. Stephen Miller, who has openly mouthed more Nazi-like slogans than any powerful American official since before World War II, is now White House Chief of Staff (we’ll get to Mr. Miller a little more below). They will still have a primary influence over the national agenda and voters’ attention. Additionally, the House Republicans who survived the 2026 political massacre have elected U.S. OH Rep. Jim Jordan, as rabid a MAGA as there is, as their minority leader. These three are not exactly conciliatory guys. Given their willingness to disregard Constitutional limitations and the effectiveness of alt-right media propaganda, they’ll remain incredibly formidable foes. 2028 is the Democrats’ other bookend. In a presidential election year, absent a true national emergency like COVID, nothing of any legislative consequence will be achieved. Americans’ perception as to how Democrats performed with their handsome 2026 majorities will already be baked in. By January 1, 2028, Democrats will need to have demonstrated that they have meaningfully addressed the 2026 voters’ concerns — or establish and effectively communicate a case for why they haven’t. Assuming our democracy survives – despite the Democrats’ majorities, with Mr. Miller ascendant one must still add that caveat – in the next election they won’t have Mr. Trump as a campaign crutch.
Although I haven’t seen much suggestion that Democrats are contemplating this, LET’S START WITH THE ONE THING DEMOCRATS ABSOLUTELY SHOULDN’T DO: IMPEACH MR. TRUMP. Democrats’ majorities derived primarily from pocketbook issues (exacerbated by the Iran War), the Regime’s Nazi-like ICE tactics, and the Trump Regime corruption. Any time Democrats spend impeaching a lame duck will both give the President oxygen and leave voters frustrated that they are playing politics. To the extent they can – there are exceptions noted below, and Mr. Trump will obviously NOT yield center stage — they should let Mr. Trump babble on.
A related aside – and a point of view for which I’m pretty sure I’m a minority of one, based upon reports of “livid” Democrats and irritated friends who were angered at Democrats who didn’t show up recently to vote to impeach Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth — I believe that Democrats missed a speeding bullet when House Republicans successfully tabled the impeachment resolution. I would submit that if the lame duck House would have continued impeachment proceedings, the process – commenced by Republican outgoing U.S. KY Rep. Thomas Massie as a pre-election trap for his fellow Republicans — would have been a trap sprung on the Democrats. I have noted here how abjectly unqualified, objectively and morally, Mr. Hegseth is for his post and wholeheartedly concur that from a substantive perspective, Mr. Hegseth should be removed. That said, had the process continued: the whole proceeding would have been no more than a symbolic show to politically burn Mr. Hegseth – who simply does Mr. Trump’s bidding — in effigy for Mr. Trump; the process would have enabled the alt-right propaganda machine to rally its base; Mr. Hegseth would almost certainly have been acquitted in the Senate, enabling him to declare a “win”; even if he was removed, Messrs. Trump and Miller would simply have installed a series of flunky “Acting” Secretaries for their last two years (since the Democratic Senate would never confirm a Secretary candidate acceptable to them) as immoral and inept as Mr. Hegseth; Democrats would have lost a useful political foil; and the most damaging – a lot of Americans wouldn’t have understood that the new members of Congress they voted for hadn’t even taken office yet, and blame them for placing politics above their concerns.
Whew! Long prelude. I would suggest that when assuming control of Congress in 2027, Democrats follow two tracks, equally important:
Track 1. Develop an effective communication structure.
No substance yet; I have placed Communication first to emphasize its importance. In the battle for democracy, voters’ perceptions are as important as reality. I think virtually all economists agree that despite the New Deal, America didn’t emerge from the Great Depression until we began World War II industrial production. Even so, through President Franklin Roosevelt’s unsurpassed communication skills and the activity he generated, the vast majority of impoverished Americans understood that he was working for them. Democrats had better understand that perception is as important as reality. If they don’t, they are going to lose 2027 politically, no matter what they do substantively.
The next point: Democrats — as much as they still love former President Barack Obama – need to learn from Mr. Obama’s mistake: He created expectations he didn’t – indeed, couldn’t — meet. Over the years, I’ve heard pundits note that they considered it ironic that so many 2008 and 2012 Obama voters have voted for Mr. Trump ever since. I see no irony. One might ponder whether these voters didn’t consider the charismatic Mr. Obama their last hope – The Audacity of Hope; “Yes, We Can” — and when it turned out that No, We Couldn’t – i.e., that their personal circumstances and prospects only worsened over the Obama years [the Affordable Care Act (the “ACA”) was a win, but I will venture that most, if forced to choose, would opt for a good job over good health care] — they were receptive to Mr. Trump’s dark message of American carnage. (TLOML and I recently visited the Obama Presidential Museum. I found it impressive, but was struck that its theme was as much on what Mr. Obama inspired as on what he accomplished. While its message was clearly intended as a pointed rebuke to Trumpism, I also considered it perhaps a rueful acknowledgement that Mr. Trump’s rise had demonstrated that Mr. Obama had not brought about the Age of Aquarius.)
Democrats need to effectively set and manage the expectations of those who voted for them. Although Democrats will handily control both chambers of Congress, most if not all of the substantive measures I suggest in Track 2 will NOT become law; many will die in the Senate due to the filibuster (Democrats should NOT end the filibuster; what goes around always comes around), and those that reach Mr. Trump will be vetoed. That’s the likelihood, so the Democrats’ primary purpose in Track 1 is to maintain the confidence of the target audiences that voted for them: progressives, liberals, independents, moderate conservatives and disgruntled MAGAs. Crucially, they need to think not only of New York and California, but of Kansas, Texas, and South Carolina. They must not only do but effectively communicate through alt-right noise that they have done their level best to fulfill their campaign promises – and that any shortcomings are Mr. Trump’s and Senate Republicans’ fault.
I hereby declare without my normal annoying qualifiers that both purported Speaker of the House U.S. NY Rep. Hakeem Jeffries and purported Senate Majority Leader U.S. NY Sen. Chuck Schumer, while effective backroom operators, have spent too much time in Washington political wars and are awful communicators. (Mr. Jeffries is merely pretty bad; Mr. Schumer is atrocious.) Cases in point: when word reached them that Mr. Trump had promoted Mr. Miller to Chief of Staff, Mr. Schumer posted, “Donald Trump learned nothing from his historic defeat. Stephen Miller is the architect of the most barbaric, inhumane policies of this administration. … Our Democratic majorities will fight him every step of the way.” Mr. Jeffries recently replied, “No,” when asked if he could work with Mr. Miller and called Mr. Miller a “stone cold racist.” I was shocked at their short-sightedness. Of course, Mr. Miller is such architect and is a stone cold racist; in this context, that’s not the point. By these two worthies declaring that they won’t work with Mr. Miller before any issue has been joined means that they’ve learned nothing from their historic victory. (Another example of oblivious counterproductive partisanship that smacks of vendetta: the tweet by U.S. CA Rep. Robert Garcia, who is set to become the Chairman of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, the day after the election: “Lawyer up.”) The voters didn’t hire Democrats to fight; they hired Democrats to help them. Although Mr. Trump would have elevated Mr. Miller anyway, I’m sure that when he heard Messrs. Schumer’s and Jeffries’ responses, he relished the fact that he owned them — again. That they took the bait – again. (These guys never learn.) Although I remain leery that Michigan Senator-Elect Abdul El-Sayed is too progressive and too impatient for the incrementalist approach I set forth in Track 2, he – a newcomer from a swing state — was much savvier when recently asked about Mr. Miller: “[T]his is a White House we’re going to have to figure out how to engage with. [Whether Democrats can work with Mr. Miller] is a choice Stephen Miller is going to have to make.”
If they haven’t already, Congressional Democrats need to hire a really able liberal publicist immediately – and communicate in the ways and manners s/he tells them. Hire a Donny Deutsch type (no plug for Mr. Deutsch; he’s the only one I know by name, from his MSNOW appearances). For the last 60 years – with the exception of former President Bill Clinton’s terms of office — Republicans have been tremendously better at messaging than Democrats. [A case to illustrate the importance of communication: below I recommend that Democrats pass a bill repealing the Big Beautiful Bill’s (the “BBB’s) extension of the 2017 Trump tax cuts for all individuals/households making over $200,000/$250,000/year. How the voters would perceive such a measure depends on messaging. Will it be, “We’re taxing the rich” – a winner? Or “They’re raising taxes” – a loser?] Equally important: Mr. Schumer should make both Kansas Senator-Elect Adam Hamilton and Mr. El-Sayed part of his leadership team (Mr. Jeffries should make parallel appointments). It’s a plus that neither currently appear to be supporting him for Senate Majority Leader; you’d rather – to cite former President Lyndon Johnson, as effective a Senate Majority Leader as we’ve ever had – have them in the tent, pissing out, than outside the tent, pissing in 😉; and every time the Democrats put Mr. Hamilton rather than Mr. Schumer in front of the microphone to explain why Democrats are taking a given position, it will be pure political gold.
Track 2. Act Substantively.
Yes, finally. 😊
Putting aside what one might otherwise think of former President Richard Nixon and former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, I think most experts view their strategic conduct of foreign policy among the finest in American history. One of its strongest attributes: they had no illusions that whatever they effected would last forever. They saw their role as furthering America’s interests in the world’s then-current conditions. One accomplished what one could today, with an eye to tomorrow.
In the preceding post, I ventured that the recent election’s outcome was determined by (1) instincts for survival by “other” Americans against the Trump Regime’s efforts to figuratively or literally purge them and financially-stressed Americans against Trump policies worsening their economic plight and (2) betrayed outrage by Trump voters who perceived themselves ignored as Mr. Trump pursued vanity projects and self-enrichment. Absent a national emergency, the Democrats should focus exclusively on measures addressing their voters’ concerns for personal and economic survival and of betrayed outrage, while emulating Messrs. Nixon’s and Kissinger’s incremental foreign policy approach – i.e., further the 2026 voters’ interests and gain their confidence in 2027, with an eye to achieving more in 2029.
An aside: I have heard liberal talking heads debate whether the 2026 majority was voting against Mr. Trump or for Democrats. It is a debate for the oblivious. They were voting against Mr. Trump. Hearkening back to Mr. Roosevelt, I would submit that the recent election, although a midterm, may be most like the 1932 election. That year, Americans didn’t award the Democrats their landslide victory due to any policy they presented, because during the campaign Mr. Roosevelt smiled and waved while remaining conspicuously silent about what he would do if elected. (Some historians think that his reticence derived in large part from the fact that he didn’t know what he was going to do if elected; he ended up just trying stuff, as he had as Governor of New York.) Desperate Americans voted for Mr. Roosevelt and Democrats that year because they weren’t Mr. Hoover and the Republicans. As I mentioned above, through his actions and communication skills Mr. Roosevelt thereafter earned the American people’s confidence. For progressives and liberals to read any greater mandate in their recent landslide than a repudiation of Mr. Trump would be dangerous delusion.
At the time this is typed, Democrats are projected to have a 56 – 44 majority in the next Senate and a 259 – 176 majority in the House of Representatives. At the same time, they will have as widely differing perspectives in their respective caucuses as Messrs. Hamilton and El-Sayed. I consider this an advantage to prevent Democrats from self-destructing by overreaching (i.e., being Democrats). These would be the Noise Rules for Democrats for 2027 😊:
- If a measure can’t get 53 Senate votes and 235 House votes, don’t go for it.
- Be Fast. You can’t afford to waste six months diddling over nits – in other words, being Democrats.
- Be Simple. You can’t afford to try to remake the world overnight – in other words, being Democrats.
- Make Messrs. Trump and Miller and Senate Republicans say No. Democrats should employ the approach used by Republicans against the ACA in the years immediately after its passage: they kept voting to repeal it although they knew that there was no chance (at that time) that such repeal could be achieved; it played well on Fox News. I actually laughed when I heard Mr. Trump tout Mr. Miller’s political instincts when appointing him White House Chief of Staff. Mr. Miller has no political instincts; he’s a zealot who doubled down on ICE’s Nazi Sturmabteilung tactics after the killing of Renee Good, alienating Minnesota, which up to then was beginning to lean Republican, and continued repressive ICE operations in both Maine (where Democrats were already targeting Republican U.S. ME Sen. Susan Collins) and Texas (with a huge Latino vote). Mr. Miller is not a stupid man; he probably understands that this Trump term will be his only chance to try to effect an American Apartheid. He is damning the torpedoes. I recently heard one pundit comment, in a reference to The Godfather, that in selecting Mr. Miller as White House Chief of Staff, Mr. Trump had selected “a wartime consigliere.” In the second instance within this note where I am probably a minority of one: I consider Mr. Miller’s appointment an asset for Democrats. The guy can’t help himself. He will just not be able to resist saying, “No,” no matter what the Democrats propose. If Democrats are at all adept – i.e., if they don’t act like Democrats – it will be easy to make any lack of progress toward addressing their voters’ concerns Mr. Miller’s fault; all they have to do is make sure that every offer they make to this wartime consigliere is one that the majority of Americans agree he can’t refuse – but he still will.
What follows is the Noise list of potential Democratic incremental initiatives that are seemingly likely to pass the Noise’s “53/235” test, address their voters’ concerns about survival and betrayal, are simple to understand and explain, can be drafted and voted upon quickly, and will leave Republicans looking like schmucks if they resist. There are only a few attempts to address detail; for most, as Cicero said in The Laws: “[What] I shall promulgate will not be complete in detail … but will present the gist and sense of the provisions.” 😊
- The knottiest first (and the longest dissertation here): the Iran war. Clearly, the vast majority of Democrats’ 2026 voters want the war to end. All of these want to avoid additional American casualties in this debacle, and some may oppose the war out of a true belief in isolationism, but I suspect that most 2026 Democratic voters primarily want it ended because they understand that it is the major driver of the inflation currently financially endangering them. It’s not clear to me that this latter group realizes that simply “ending the war” – perhaps by Democrats cutting off its funding, as some have called for — won’t get them inflation relief unless the Strait of Hormuz is open, enabling energy prices to come down. This is a hellishly difficult issue; there is no practical way that Congressional Democrats can meaningfully direct a war already in progress – this ain’t 1789 — and at the same time, their 2026 voters expect them to do something. Instead of cutting off funding, they should pass a bill (1) removing all financial sanctions on Iran upon the President’s certification that (i) Iran is not engaging in violent activities against the citizens and assets of the United States and its allies and (ii) Iran is allowing the financially free and unfettered passage of ships through the Strait of Hormuz (and any other relevant body of water) and (2) requiring the President to provide such certification within 7 days after the President has made such determination. (I know, I know; but face it: Mr. Trump is still President and Commander in Chief.) This is a straight swap of limited scope: de facto lower inflation in return for enabling Iran to obtain needed cash. With Mr. Trump now manifestly politically weakened, the Iranians might like the swap. From a geopolitical strategic standpoint, it’s a terrible deal. At the same time, since Iran almost certainly won’t desist from violent activities no matter what it agrees to, we can snap back the sanctions (and incur the consequent challenge in the Strait of Hormuz) if Iran’s transgression is sufficiently inflammatory that American public opinion supports such an approach. The foreign policy geek in me is screaming about the nuclear threat, but it’s a delusion to think that Mr. Trump will get anything substantive done during the rest of his term; we’ll have to leave that to the next president to either address the concern peacefully – or make the case to the American people why military intervention is warranted.
- Pass a bill rolling back any increased tariffs imposed by the Trump Administration during the last two years – with particular focus on tariffs affecting our farmers, ranchers and our relationship with Canada — and restricting the tariff powers that Congress has previously provided the President. (This will require carveouts for true national security concerns, perhaps requiring Congressional approval. Lawyers say, “Hard cases make bad law.” I hate the notion that the fetters needed to restrict Mr. Trump may hereafter impede a rational president, but see no alternative.)
- Pass a bill repealing the BBB’s reduction in food and health care cost subsidies and Medicare’s drug-pricing negotiation authority, but including stronger penalties for fraud.
- Pass a bill repealing the BBB’s income tax rates for all taxpayers annually making more than $200,000 individually ($250,000 per a household), returning these higher-income taxpayers to pre-2018 brackets (adjusted for inflation) and marginal rates.
- Pass a bill requiring federal immigration agents within the United States (i.e., not at the border): to identify themselves when apprehending suspects; banning the use of masks by immigration agents; generally banning ICE’s use of administrative warrants; requiring ICE agents engaged in apprehensions to have activated body cameras; providing for immediate dismissal of ICE agents proven to not be wearing activated body cameras during apprehensions except under extraordinary circumstances; providing recourse against the federal government and individual ICE agents for American citizens who are wrongly detained by immigration officials; providing for standards for detention centers, particularly with regard to children, and inspections by independent agencies; providing full access to local authorities in the investigation of any injury or death occurring during an ICE apprehension; etc., etc., etc. (The key is to not go too far; Democrats need to avoid alienating citizens concerned about illegal immigration by recognizing that undocumented individuals – including those otherwise law-abiding, and contribute materially to our communities and the economy – are, indeed, criminals.)
- Pass a bill reconstituting the Civil Rights Act in a manner that reestablishes voting protections for Black Americans that finesses the recent Supreme Court rulings viewed by Constitutional scholars as gutting the purpose of the Act. (I don’t know what provisions should be adopted, but am confident that there are those who do.)
- Pass a bill increasing the current federal minimum wage of $7.25 by $1.50/yr. in each of the next five years, with annual increases thereafter calculated by the Social Security COLA. (Under such a proposal, full-time minimum wage work wouldn’t earn $30,000 until about 2032 – hardly a windfall.)
- Pass a bill prohibiting the construction of Data Centers intended to support Artificial Intelligence initiatives without approval by local referendum.
- Pass job training bills designed to enable Americans to prepare for jobs that experts do not consider easily assumed by AI or robotics in the foreseeable future.
- Pass a bill facilitating and subsidizing day care – a major hindrance and expense for working class Americans.
- Pass a bill ensuring nationwide abortion rights for the first 15 weeks of a pregnancy – the period which has wide American support. Don’t overreach.
- Pass a bill providing a path to citizenship for DACA registrants.
- Pass a bill providing for aggressive aid to Ukraine and imposing even deeper sanctions on Russia than provided for in the recently-passed “Graham Honor Bill.” (Virtually no Americans like Russian President Vladimir Putin. 😊)
- If such does not exist, pass a bill that will sanction any American government contractor who is found to have adversely affected the Ukrainian war effort or materially aided the Russian invasion.
- Pass a bill that bans ownership by members of Congress of publicly traded individual stocks and industry-specific mutual funds.
- As to Mr. Trump: Be surgical; don’t make him a martyr. Pass a bill killing the Arch. Pass a bill prohibiting the placement of the name of any living current or past federal office holder on a federal building.
If you think that there are additional straightforward measures Democrats could bring forth that would receive widespread American support, add them. If you think that what I have proposed is not ambitious enough, I’ve made my case for incrementalism.
Then, there are hearings. Again, the idea would be to stick to the low-hanging obvious fruit. For Democrats to go after Trump Regime ancillary White House and subcabinet officials that few have heard of – which I have inferred from Mr. Garcia’s “Lawyer Up” — is a waste of time.
- Have hearings on what Epstein Files haven’t been released, despite existing law.
- Have a hearing on Nvidia’s now-disgraced CEO Jensen Huang’s ties to China and a Chinese spy, how Nvidia’s activities may have endangered national security, what Mr. Huang and Nvidia contributed to Trump projects, what Mr. Trump and Trump Regime members knew about Mr. Huang’s Chinese connections and when they knew it, etc., etc. (Here, you get four for the price of one: Trump corruption; voter distaste for AI; voter distrust of China; and Congressional Republicans trying to defend Mr. Trump’s buddy who is an admitted adulterer who slept with a Chinese spy. 😉)
- Have a hearing on the Putin ally’s funding of Donald Trump, Jr.’s wedding reception. (I know; too easy 😊.)
- I’ve heard a number of pundits suggest that there are irregularities around the federal government’s contracts with Elon Musk’s SpaceX. Although I strongly believe that it will be counterproductive for Democrats to engage in vendettas, if – and only if — there is true substance to these allegations, hold hearings. (Democrats don’t have to be careful with Mr. Musk. No American of any political stripe likes Mr. Musk except Wall Streeters.)
- Hold hearings to find out how Americans’ tax and other personal data was examined and used during DOGE activities, and where such data may now be stored. (Many Americans may not have been offended by DOGE’s activities to trim the federal workforce, but no American likes the idea that DOGErs were looking at and moving their personal data.)
- Have a hearing exploring funding for the East Wing Ballroom, what it will cost taxpayers, the contractor selection process, and the competence of the undertaking (initial plans featured a staircase leading to a brick wall.)
- Have a hearing on the grounds upon which Mr. Hegseth has dismissed a huge number of our leading officers.
- The only complex one: Have hearings on the benefits and dangers of Artificial Intelligence. We need it, but understandably fear it. The issues here are too important to wait for the next president, although legislation will almost certainly have to wait until 2029.
- Overall, keep it simple. If there are other glaring examples where Trump insiders have profited from the taxpayers, go for it; but no matter how morally outrageous some Trump stunt might be, if it can’t be easily understood and doesn’t endanger national security, ignore it.
There are two categories of issues that I sadly consider best avoided – the substantively complex and politically toxic: Federal Debt reduction (everybody wants to cut the debt and deficit by cutting the other guy’s programs); Social Security and Medicare reform (ditto); anything that smacks of identity politics and gender issues (except for the abortion bill described above); gun regulation; substantive immigration reform (as contrasted with ICE regulation); vaccines; ACA restructuring/Medicare for All; a wealth tax (too hard to create and explain reasonable exemptions for family farmers, etc.); “green” legislation; and sanctions on Israeli excesses. All of these issues vitally need consideration by serious people and collaboration between the President and the Congress. This will not be feasible at least until 2029. If Democrats achieve even half of what I suggested above, hopefully they will have earned the confidence of their 2026 voters.
As we sit here today, I am not at all convinced that a large share of Democratic Party officialdom actually understands the collective sentiments of “the people” that it claims to want to represent and voted for them in 2026. I am currently firmly in their camp despite my evident exasperation with them simply because they haven’t taken any steps to subvert our democracy – unlike the Republican Party since Donald Trump staged his hostile takeover. I have the most fervent hope that the very breadth of their victory will require them to heed voices toward the middle of the political spectrum – which is where most Americans actually are. I would love to see them be so successful that Trumpism is reduced to a splinter movement by 2028 – which would enable this moderate to again have the luxury of shaking his head at their well-meaning excesses. We’re still far, far from that point.
As I said at the outset: If you’ve made it this far, I applaud your perseverance. 😊
We’ll see what happens.